Nestled in the picturesque Cherry Grove, New York, Cherry Grove Pizza is more than just a dining spot; it’s a culinary gem that captures the essence of Fire Island. Located at 179 Ocean Walk, this vibrant pizzeria invites guests to indulge in a delectable array of traditional Italian fares that resonate with locals and visitors alike. Whether it’s a sunny afternoon or a cozy evening, this place has the perfect ambiance to complement its mouth-watering offerings.

Renowned for its incredible pizza, Cherry Grove Pizza has gained rave reviews from enthusiastic patrons. Take, for example, the eggplant rollatini pie—a standout dish that has won the hearts of many. Customer Korey Heester passionately remarked on its outstanding taste, praising the attentive service provided by the charming server, Michael. Such dedication to both quality food and excellent service turns a simple meal into a cherished experience.

Another delightful highlight at Cherry Grove Pizza is the generous servings and rich toppings that customers rave about. As noted by Mike North, his experience entailed not just an amazing pizza but also unforgettable meatballs, all enjoyed in an atmosphere filled with warm smiles and engaging staff interactions. The attentive service makes every visit feel special, fostering a connection between the guests and the hardworking team.

The offerings extend beyond pizzas; the restaurant provides a variety of other delicious options like Garlic Knot slices and Chicken Parm Hero’s, treasured by regulars like Demetria Kess. The personal touch from staff, exemplified by their ability to remember names, enhances the dining experience, making it feel uniquely inviting.

Giovanni Amador lauded the ambiance and service during his visit, highlighting the delicious chicken hero, perfectly cooked and enjoyed with attentive care from the servers. It's clear that here, every detail—from the cooking to the friendly service—is meticulously crafted to delight patrons and create lasting memories.

If you're lucky enough to stop by, don’t miss out on their fried shrimp with a Caesar salad, noted by Ethan Normandy as a remarkable dish. His enthusiastic recommendation encapsulates the spirit of Cherry Grove Pizza: a place where the food exceeds expectations and the service is unforgettable.

In conclusion, if you find yourself on the enchanting Fire Island, make a point to visit Cherry Grove Pizza. With a menu that tantalizes the taste buds and a staff committed to making every meal a joyful affair, it's an experience you won't want to miss.